Early rating research
Samuel J. Rosch’s work on rubber-insulated conductors helped establish a foundation for standardized cable ratings.
Explore Neher-McGrath calculations and the science of underground cable heating. Trace the heat, examine the assumptions, and discover what determines a cable’s thermal performance.
A cable rating is also a heat-transfer problem.
Buried cables lose heat through their insulation, ducts, concrete, backfill, and surrounding ground. Nearby loaded circuits add heat to that same environment. The resulting conductor temperature depends on the entire installation, not just the conductor size.
A thermal calculation answers two related questions: What temperature will a specified current produce? And what current can the installation carry without exceeding its temperature limits? The second answer is the cable’s ampacity for those modeled conditions.
Standard ampacity tables represent defined conditions. Where the actual burial depth, circuit arrangement, materials, or loading differs from those conditions, a project-specific analysis helps identify the controlling location and evaluate design alternatives.
Samuel J. Rosch’s work on rubber-insulated conductors helped establish a foundation for standardized cable ratings.
J. H. Neher and M. H. McGrath published The Calculation of the Temperature Rise and Load Capability of Cable Systems, linking cable losses, heat transfer, and load capability.
Analytical rating methods remain useful. Numerical models extend the analysis to detailed material boundaries and temperature fields; time-dependent models examine changing loads.
Choose a model for the question, geometry, and available data.
Represents heat flow with thermal resistances and analytical relationships, including interactions between heat sources.
Balances heat flowing into, out of, and being generated within control volumes across a two-dimensional cross section.
Approximates temperature with element shape functions over a mesh that can follow material boundaries.
| What is being evaluated? | Neher-McGrathANALYTICAL RATING METHOD | 2D FVMFINITE VOLUME METHOD | FEM2D FINITE-ELEMENT MODEL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solution approach | Thermal-resistance relationships and coupled heat-source calculations. | Conservation-of-energy balances over grid cells or control volumes. | Element equations assembled from a weak formulation of the heat equation. |
| Temperature at a specified current | SUPPORTEDWithin the method’s assumptions and supported geometry. | SUPPORTEDCalculated from specified heat sources and boundary conditions. | SUPPORTEDCalculated from specified heat sources and boundary conditions. |
| Ampacity at a temperature limit | CORE APPLICATIONSolve the rating relationships for allowable current. | WITH A RATING SOLVEAdjust current until the controlling temperature reaches its limit. | WITH A RATING SOLVEUse iteration, optimization, or an equivalent constrained solution. |
| Mutual heating between circuits | SUPPORTEDAnalytical interaction terms for supported arrangements. | SUPPORTEDMultiple heat sources share the computed thermal field. | SUPPORTEDMultiple heat sources share the computed thermal field. |
| Concrete, backfill & layered soil | REPRESENTATION DEPENDENTEquivalent regions or available analytical corrections; arbitrary boundaries are limited. | SPATIALLY RESOLVEDMaterial properties represented on the grid; interface treatment matters. | SPATIALLY RESOLVEDSeparate material domains with mesh-conforming interfaces. |
| Irregular shapes & curved interfaces | IDEALIZATION OFTEN NEEDEDRequires a supported analytical representation. | GRID DEPENDENTRefinement or cut-cell/body-fitted techniques may be needed. | FLEXIBLE MESHINGElements can follow complex boundaries; mesh quality still matters. |
| Temperature contours & heat flux | ADDITIONAL RECONSTRUCTIONA full spatial field is not the primary network output. | FIELD OUTPUTTemperatures and derived heat flux across the grid. | FIELD OUTPUTTemperatures and derived heat flux across the mesh. |
| Electrical, dielectric & metallic losses | LOSS RELATIONSHIPSAppropriate cable-loss terms must be included. | SPECIFY OR COUPLEA thermal solver needs loss inputs or an electrical model. | SPECIFY OR COUPLEFEM alone does not define losses; use inputs or coupled electromagnetics. |
| Changing loads & time to equilibrium | EXTENDED MODEL REQUIREDDaily loss-factor treatment is not a full time-history solution. | TRANSIENT SOLVER REQUIREDNeeds heat capacity, initial conditions, and time-dependent loads. | TRANSIENT SOLVER REQUIREDNeeds heat capacity, initial conditions, and time-dependent loads. |
| Soil dry-out & changing properties | SPECIAL TREATMENT REQUIREDUse an appropriate dry-zone model or defined material scenarios. | SPECIAL TREATMENT REQUIREDNeeds a property law, prescribed dry zone, or coupled moisture model. | SPECIAL TREATMENT REQUIREDNeeds a property law, prescribed dry zone, or coupled moisture model. |
| Crossings & changes along the route | SPECIAL ANALYSISA uniform-section calculation does not resolve a localized crossing. | 2D LIMITATIONA cross section omits longitudinal heat flow; consider 3D. | 2D LIMITATIONA 3D FEM model may be needed for the local geometry. |
| Checks that establish confidence | Verify loss terms, geometry assumptions, load factors, and reference cases. | Verify energy balance, grid convergence, domain size, boundaries, and benchmarks. | Verify energy balance, mesh convergence, domain size, boundaries, and benchmarks. |
Read “supported” as a capability of a properly formulated model, not an automatic feature of every program. FVM = finite volume method. FEM = finite element method.
A fine mesh cannot correct uncertain soil data or an incorrect loading assumption. Compare methods using the same geometry, losses, material properties, boundary conditions, and temperature criteria before interpreting differences.
Transient analysis adds “when?” A time-to-equilibrium result requires a stated tolerance, such as reaching a specified fraction of the final temperature rise, because equilibrium is generally approached gradually.
The comparison is an engineering synthesis of method capabilities. It is not a verification statement for Cable View Web or another specific solver.
Start with a simplified heat-balance experiment. Adjust the inputs and watch the response.
Illustrative equivalent thermal circuit
Fixed geometry • Continuous loading
Compared with an illustrative 90 °C temperature limit.
Per modeled conductor.
This demonstration uses T = Ta + I²R × Rθ, with fixed conductor resistance R = 0.000075 Ω/m and effective thermal resistance Rθ = 2 + 2ρ (ρ in K·m/W). Input resistivity is converted from °C·cm/W by dividing by 100. The effective resistance is an illustrative teaching parameter, not a duct bank solution. It excludes temperature-dependent resistance, dielectric and shield losses, and position-specific mutual heating. All nine displayed ducts use one equivalent temperature. Contours are conceptual graphics, not computed FEM results. This prototype is not a validated Neher-McGrath calculation or a design rating.
Choose a scenario to load its inputs into the laboratory.
Cable View Web is being developed as the calculation tool for Neher-McGrath.net. This will be the place to open the application and evaluate an underground cable installation.
The Cable View Web preview is now available for educational use. Explore conductor temperatures, ampacity, and the 2D finite-volume temperature map.
Open Cable View Web →Cable View is a developing family of tools for exploring cable thermal performance. This space will document the methods, interfaces, and verification behind the work.
Underground cable ampacity and duct bank thermal analysis.
A planned standalone tool for exploring transient heating and the approach to thermal equilibrium.
Exploring how soil thermal behavior can affect underground cable performance.
Benchmark cases, documented assumptions, and comparisons between calculation methods.